Are SA wines "too white"?

Just how much is the traditionally "white" wine industry in South Africa doing the BEE thing?

by: Cathrine Shone: Restaurant Editor | 18 Aug 2009

Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) in the liquor industry in South Africa is at full pace, particularly with the largest commercial brands throwing their considerable weight behind it.

  • The historical Boschendal estate changed hands at the end of 2003 in a black empowerment deal valued at R323 million.
  • Wine and spirits producer KWV Limited signed a deal with Phetogo Investments, a black empowerment consortium, in 2004.
  • JSE-listed wine and spirits producer Distell’s BEE sold a 15% stake in its 100%-owned sole operating subsidiary, South African Distilleries and Wines (SADW), to an empowerment consortium.
  • Most recently SABMiller the world's number two brewer, sold a tenth of its South African operation to black investors in a deal worth R6 billion.

    But perhaps the most heartening integration of the BEE initiative has been in the wine industry. Traditionally a “white” South African industry, the wind of transformation is blowing through the vineyards of the Western Cape – and it is being embraced.

    Socially responsible wines
    Wine companies are subject to The South African wine industry BEE Charter and Scorecard, to ensure they meet certain government-ordained quotas for black ownership, employment and procurement. To get a sense of the myriad of BEE deals in the winelands, just take a gander at the WOSA ( Wines of South Africa ) website.

    It’s hugely encouraging to see so many estate owners getting involved in the process of positively empowering their employees and ensuring the industry becomes more socially responsible. In terms of ownership the wine industry may be behind other industries, with only 1% of companies being black owned, but the investment in people, training and social welfare is where they are making the biggest difference.

    With regards to the export arena, British quaffers now have the opportunity to support black owned wines if they choose to. Ses'fikile, founded by three black female entrepreneurs, two of whom were school teachers in the townships and M'hudi, founded by the Rangaka's, a family of black professionals, are available at Marks & Spencer. Thandi, the world's first fair trade wine owned by a black workers' trust, is available alongside a couple of others via websites like

    Back in South Africa, the consumer trend is still very much with the traditional and ubiquitous white-owned wine estates. The general public are blind to who owns what, and what wine they consume/buy is largely due to lack of awareness and general apathy. But the drive is on to awaken perception, and should we be paying more attention?

    But if we did know, would we care? Would you choose a BEE label over a white-owned one?

    - None


  • publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

    Comment on this story
    Comments have been closed for this article.
    There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.