The Taste of Cape Town
This amazing festival promises to be the culinary event of the year.
Vinatics
Join Food24's new drinking club!
 
 

Japan pushes whaling as consumers' appetite fades

by: Reuters: Elaine Lies
 
Image by:
 

Whaleburgers are on the menu at a restaurant in Wada, a coastal whaling town southeast of Tokyo, to lure back young customers.

"If you just serve whale raw, young people won't eat it," says Akiji Ichihara, who serves whale hamburgers with salad, mayonnaise and tomato sauce, once a month at his restaurant.

"So I decided to put it between bread, to encourage more people to eat whale. Whale is part of our food culture, so I wish it could be made more available."

Keen to resume commercial hunts banned by the International Whaling Commission (IWC) in 1986, Japan will hosted a special gathering of IWC nations before its annual meeting in May.

Japanese officials argue a blanket ban on whaling is not needed since some species have recovered enough to be hunted again, and want to shift the IWC's emphasis to whale management.

They also say they hope the gathering will promote dialogue within the increasingly polarised organisation.

Despite their government's dedication to whaling in the face of harsh international criticism, appetite for the delicacy is waning among ordinary Japanese

"I don't really want to eat whale, though I have in the past," said Hitoko Makigaki, 44, as she took a cigarette break outside in downtown Tokyo. "The number of whales is falling and there's a lot of other good things to eat these days."

The nonchalance contrasts with the alarm that greeted cuts in Japan's quota for bluefin tuna, a prized sushi ingredient.

"As for whale, I can take it or leave it," said Yuji Sasaki, 39, who works for a marketing firm. "Tuna is much tastier."

Waning appetites
Many older Japanese ate whale in school lunches after it was introduced under U.S. Occupation , when whale was an important source of protein for an economically devastated Japan.

Appetites waned when prices rose after the 1986 whaling ban.

"There was a time when there was only whale to eat and we didn't have meat. We had no choice," said Yoko Tomiyama, chairwoman of the Consumers' Union of Japan.

"But I really wonder why the state now is so reluctant to stop whaling and instead is pushing whale on people."

Japan, which says whaling is a cherished cultural tradition , began what it calls scientific research whaling in 1987. The meat, which under IWC rules must be sold for consumption, ends up in pricey restaurants and on supermarket shelves, but is far from a daily menu choice. Whale meat stockpiles rose to 4,403 tonnes as of last November from 3,634 tonnes at the end of 2005, according to the Fisheries Agency.

Activists argue the glut proves a decline in popular demand.

"Unless they manage to sell the whale they take, they can't keep on with scientific whaling," said Nanami Kurasawa, secretary-general of the Dolphin & Whale Action Network, an environmental group. "They have to sell to hunt."

Last year a company was set up to expand the sale of whale meat to hospitals, school lunch caterers and restaurant chains. While the government touts whale as healthy and high in protein, and a number of primary schools served it in lunches last month.

"Eating is a private choice. We don't think the government should be interfering, giving out money and promoting whale in schools," said Tomiyama, the Consumers' Union chairwoman.

(Additional reporting by Takanori Isshiki)

- None

 
 
 

Comment on this story

 
 
Lejane Hardy
5/18/2007 6:24:58 AM
This is something that I do not understand at all. The Japanese insist on continuing with whaling in the face of huge opposition, spend millions to bribe countries into voting for whaling, promise the earth to countries to countries to vote for whaling and yet a VERY large portion of their countrymen don't want the product. It doesn't even make good economic sense - perhaps its just about votes now. It's the same in Canada - although seal skin and seal products are now banned in many countries around the world, the return on the investment made is negligible, opposition to sealers burtality is growing daily and yet still Canada continues - again, it seems such a waste when they could actually be making more money out of the seals by bringing in tourists to see the land and the beauty of the animals.
 
LM
5/18/2007 7:47:24 AM
Humans do not have to indulge in the flesh of a intelligent, self-aware and endangered living being. To hell with tradition. If tradition prevailed, we would still be burning witches at the stake and accusing scientist of witchcraft. The world has moved on and so must they.
 
edna
5/18/2007 9:17:12 AM
Do you not support the fact that whaling is banned? Can you not add your voice to those opposing it instead of making it look acceptable? You lose credibility with this article and seem greedy, glutinous and uncaring.
 
Robyn
5/18/2007 9:22:49 AM
I wonder...yes, it does not make economic sense, but is it sick? Why? Because the whale is a mammal? Then I guess having a good old sirloin steak isn't very cool either.I agree, if a demand does not exist, then the trade should be minimalzed.That would make sense. Sell what's left and then supply only to those who desire it. I've never had whale, but to be honest I won't say that I never will.I am no vegetarian and the only animals I strongly would object to eating are those that can be kept as pets.Whales don't fall under that category.
 
EW
5/18/2007 9:24:43 AM
"The time will come when men such as I will look upon the murder of animals as they now look on the murder of men." -Leonardo da Vinci
 
toni
5/18/2007 9:50:10 AM
Just because some whale species are experiencing positive growth it is acceptable to hunt them? While the world and many Japanese wail about the continued government insistence that whale hunting will continue, these gentle giants continue to die horrifically painful deaths. Sadly it seems that the Japanese government believes that they have to save face somehow by insisting they are right, despite the growing evidence that whaling reduces these beings to dog food and is NOT part of tradition.
 
Carla Blankevoort
5/19/2007 6:52:14 PM
Yet again, it seems that governments make decisions despite the opinions of their people. In Japans case it is probably to fly in the face of popular Western norms and perpetuate whaling "just because we can" Yes, too many innocent beasts are killed for mans greed but these animals die protracted and painful deaths for no compelling reason.
 
Lejane
5/21/2007 6:48:52 AM
I think, just to clarify things, from now on all my posts with regard to animal abuse will start with "I am vegan" so that I can be seen to post against the abuse and just for once people will have to think more about their post before saying "but i bet you like your steak". NO, Robyn, a good ol' sirloin steak and how it gets to your plate is pretty disgusting too, but even meateaters can take one or two steps in the right direction by asking why animals must be killed for NO reason whatsover. Whale meat is lying rotting in may storage facilities all over Japan, so to continue to kill these beautiful marine creatures in a torturous manner for nothing - yip, I do believe even meateaters could have a problem with that.
 
 
*
*
*
Please enter the text below:

Captcha

 

*
 
  Sign up for food24 newsletters!
   
   
 

Inside Food24

 
 
 
 
 

Today's Easy Weekday Meal

 
pasta with baked camembert Monday
Pasta with baked camembert
If you want something that will tantalize the taste buds but won't take much time, you must try this.
Prep time:  20 mins
Cooking time:  10 - 15 mins

See this week's meals
 
 
 

Heard on Food24...

Grilled spatchcock chicken
Try out this delish recipe with feta cheese stuffing. Read more...

 
 
 

Restaurants

 
simply asia
Simply Asia (Honey Crest Centre)

Simply Asia have extended for your pleasure, visit their new restaurant in Randpark Ridge.

 

Find a restaurant

 
 
 

Jobs - Find your dream job

Teller

Gauteng
First National Bank

 
 

Financial Director (AA)

KwaZulu Natal - Durban
Network Recruitment CA- Centurion
R850,000-950,000 Per Annum Cost To Company

 
 

Tax Accountant

Mpumalanga
Frontline Gauteng (Head Office)
R275,000 Per Annum Cost To Company

 
 

Cars - Search 1000's of new and used cars

TOYOTA

Yaris T3 1.3 Plus 5-dr
2008
R 139,990.00

 
 

OPEL

Corsa 1.7DTi Club Utility Dsl
2008
R 124,995.00

 
 

AUDI

A4 Avant 2.0T FSi Ambiente 155kW MY09 Multitronic
2009
R 389,000.00

 
 

Property - Find a new home

BANTRY BAY

Single Residential - House R 27 500 000

SOMERSET WEST

Single Residential - House R 18 000 000

KYALAMI ESTATES

Single Residential - House R 5 800 000

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Free Games - TOO MUCH NEWS? TAKE A BREAK!

Kalahari.net - shop online today

Kenwood 2 Slice toaster

Brushed Stainless steel. Reheat frozen bread + electronic browning!

Gordon Ramsay's World Kitchen

Gordon Ramsay has once again put together an amazing cookbook, this time featuring his favourite recipes from around the world.

Mellarware Citrus Juicer

Enjoy convenient and fresh citrus juice all day!

Gourmet Curry Hamper

Contains a Maxwell & Williams Pestle and Mortar, a selection of Spices & more!

Jamie's Ministry of Food:

Anyone Can Learn to Cook in 24 Hours

Decadent Chocolate Cake Bake

A gift box containing a baking tin, ingredients: chocolate cake mix, vanilla, Cadbury chocolate & baking paper together with a recipe for Decadent Chocolate Cake

Kenwoord Popcorn Maker

Air popped popcorn, fluffy and light

Platter's South African Wine Guide 2010

A comprehensive A-Z directory of wines & wine producers, includes GPS coordinates for all the major wineries.